Steph appears to give that due consideration, her fingers tapping idly on her arm, "Finders keepers did go out of style after fifth grade." So Kaitlyn did steal Odessa's cat, is what Steph's saying.

"But no, you don't have to worry about rumors of you kicking puppies. She was vague on why, exactly, you were dangerous," That could be fishing for details, or she could just be teasing.